Back to Stocks

NIC

NICOLET BANKSHARES INC
7 filings tracked
financialsasset managementSMALL ($300M-2B)

Company Intelligence Hub

Filing history, signal momentum, and bull/bear evolution

Chronological Filing Evolution (Click to filter / toggle)

Thesis (Bull Case Evolution)

Nicolet Bankshares is successfully transitioning from a community bank to a regional powerhouse following the strategic acquisition of MidWestOne Financial Group.…

Bullish Outlook

Antithesis (Bear Case / Structural Risks)

Despite the narrative of growth, the financial reality for Nicolet is currently defined by a significant erosion of profitability. The acquisition of MidWestOne has brought a tidal wave of integration costs, with noninterest expenses surging 130% year-over-year to $110 million.…

Risk Factors

Read the full bull/bear analysis

You are reading the free preview. Start a free trial to unlock the complete bull & bear analysis for every NIC filing.

Start Free Trial

Synthesis (Verdict & Resolution)

The first quarter 2026 filing reveals a company at a critical inflection point. On one hand, the MidWestOne acquisition has provided Nicolet with the scale and deposit base necessary to compete as a regional player, evidenced by a 54% jump in net interest income. On the other hand, the immediate cost of this growth has been steep, manifesting in compressed GAAP margins and a sharp rise in nonperforming assets. The overall impact of the filing is a shift toward a higher-risk, higher-reward profile. Investors must now weigh the impressive core performance and margin expansion against the immediate operational headwinds and the volatility of a much larger, more complex loan portfolio. The planned sale of the Denver branches in Q3 2026 will be a key indicator of management's ability to streamline the franchise and optimize the balance sheet for efficiency.

Selected Quarter

Core Takeaway

Nicolet has successfully scaled its balance sheet and expanded margins, but GAAP profitability is currently suppressed by heavy merger-related costs and rising nonperforming loans.

Investor Lens

The trade-off is between the long-term value of a larger regional platform and the short-term risk of asset quality deterioration and integration failure.

Watch Next

The closing of the Denver branch sale in Q3 2026 and the trend in nonperforming loans relative to the new ACL levels.

View Full SEC Report

Signal Momentum Chart

Quarterly net bull/bear signal ratio. Click nodes to select a quarter.

BULLISH (+1.0)NEUTRAL (0.0)BEARISH (-1.0)+0.25Q2 '26 (10-Q)

Signal Timeline

Active Filters:Quarter: Q2 '26 (10-Q)
bullishMay 6

Completed acquisition of MidWestOne, increasing total assets by 70% to $15.6 billion.

acquisition
90%
bullishMay 6

Net interest margin increased by 40 bps to 3.98%.

margin expansion
70%
bearishMay 6

GAAP net income fell 53% sequentially due to massive merger-related expenses.

earnings miss
60%
neutralMay 6

Integration of MidWestOne management and operational restructuring underway.

management change
30%
bullishMay 6

Completed acquisition of MidWestOne, increasing total assets by 70% to $15.6 billion.

acquisition
90%
bullishMay 6

Net interest margin increased by 40 bps to 3.98%.

margin expansion
70%
bearishMay 6

GAAP net income fell 53% sequentially due to massive merger-related expenses.

earnings miss
60%
neutralMay 6

Integration of MidWestOne management and operational restructuring underway.

management change
30%
bullishMay 6

Completed acquisition of MidWestOne, increasing total assets by 70% to $15.6 billion.

acquisition
90%
bullishMay 6

Net interest margin increased by 40 bps to 3.98%.

margin expansion
70%
bearishMay 6

GAAP net income fell 53% sequentially due to massive merger-related expenses.

earnings miss
60%
neutralMay 6

Integration of MidWestOne management and operational restructuring underway.

management change
30%
bullishMay 6

Completed acquisition of MidWestOne, increasing total assets by 70% to $15.6 billion.

acquisition
90%
bullishMay 6

Net interest margin increased by 40 bps to 3.98%.

margin expansion
70%
bearishMay 6

GAAP net income fell 53% sequentially due to massive merger-related expenses.

earnings miss
60%
neutralMay 6

Integration of MidWestOne management and operational restructuring underway.

management change
30%
bullishMay 6

Completed acquisition of MidWestOne, increasing total assets by 70% to $15.6 billion.

acquisition
90%
bullishMay 6

Net interest margin increased by 40 bps to 3.98%.

margin expansion
70%
bearishMay 6

GAAP net income fell 53% sequentially due to massive merger-related expenses.

earnings miss
60%
neutralMay 6

Integration of MidWestOne management and operational restructuring underway.

management change
30%
bullishMay 6

Completed acquisition of MidWestOne, increasing total assets by 70% to $15.6 billion.

acquisition
90%
bullishMay 6

Net interest margin increased by 40 bps to 3.98%.

margin expansion
70%
bearishMay 6

GAAP net income fell 53% sequentially due to massive merger-related expenses.

earnings miss
60%
neutralMay 6

Integration of MidWestOne management and operational restructuring underway.

management change
30%
bullishMay 6

Completed acquisition of MidWestOne, increasing total assets by 70% to $15.6 billion.

acquisition
90%
bullishMay 6

Net interest margin increased by 40 bps to 3.98%.

margin expansion
70%
bearishMay 6

GAAP net income fell 53% sequentially due to massive merger-related expenses.

earnings miss
60%
neutralMay 6

Integration of MidWestOne management and operational restructuring underway.

management change
30%

Filing History

10-QMay 6, 2026
Expand Sequence

The first quarter 2026 filing reveals a company at a critical inflection point. On one hand, the MidWestOne acquisition has provided Nicolet with the scale and deposit base necessary to compete as a regional player, evidenced by a 54% jump in net interest income. On the other hand, the immediate cost of this growth has been steep, manifesting in compressed GAAP margins and a sharp rise in nonperforming assets. The overall impact of the filing is a shift toward a higher-risk, higher-reward profile. Investors must now weigh the impressive core performance and margin expansion against the immediate operational headwinds and the volatility of a much larger, more complex loan portfolio. The planned sale of the Denver branches in Q3 2026 will be a key indicator of management's ability to streamline the franchise and optimize the balance sheet for efficiency.

Disclaimer: The synthesis provided is generated by AI models and should not be construed as investment advice. Analysis is based solely on regulatory data present at the time of publication. Consult a financial advisor for specific investment strategies.